Dan:
Before I get into my rant about payroll (I do this often), let me first welcome any new readers to the blog. It seems we have the featured blog on the homepage today. (Thank you blog gods.) Those who came to check out what was described as a "brotherly conversation about baseball," let me fill you in: It is a brotherly conversation, but the kind of conversation where one brother (me) is a genius on the subject of baseball and does all the talking, while the other brother (my brother Jason) sits in the corner grunting and rubbing his lobotomy scar.
Anyway, on to baseball. The Associated Press released payroll figures yesterday. Seems the Red Sox have dropped to fourth in payroll, behind the Yankees, Tigers and Mets. But don't compare the Sox to Oakland just yet; they're still paying out $133 million ($15 mill of that for J.D. Drew . . . in case you forgot).
I've always been frustrated by those who lump the Red Sox in with the Yankees when it comes to big spending. And this is why: There is a $70 million difference this year between the team with the highest payroll (Yankees at $209 million) and the team with the second-highest payroll (Tigers at $138 million). Just to put into context how much of a universe apart that is, there is a $70 million difference between the Tigers and the lowly Kansas City Royals.
Now, as we've seen in recent years, money can't buy championships. But it sure can help. Not only does it buy you free agents, it helps you absorb terrible mistakes (Carl Pavano, Jared Wright, Kevin Brown, Yanks? J.D. Drew, Matt Clement, Sox?)
But as much as my blood boils by how much teams spend (or have to spend) to be competitive, I'm equally angered by the teams at the bottom of the spectrum, where owners clearcut their payrolls, put out minor-league-quality teams, and pocket the revenue. It amounts to highway robbery. Jeffrey Loria's Florida Marlins -- with MLB's lowest payroll at $21 million -- is less than half of the next lowest team's payroll, which is Tampa Bay at $43 million. Loria already pilledged the city of Montreal, and now he seems on his way to doing the same in south Florida. This team has won two championships in the last 11 years, and this is what they're left with? This isn't just bad management; it HAS to be willful greed.
Another team is Oakland at $47 million. Sure, you can say they are well-run; they seem to be competitive three out of every five seasons. But for a team that has been as consistently competitive as they have, I just have a hard time believing they can't afford to pay out a lot more. I have a hard time believing ownership isn't seriously cashing in. (Especially considering Kansas City sits at $58 million.)
If there is going to be a cap or a luxury tax, there really should be some kind of league minimum payroll. Something where if ownership can not meet that, they risk being penalized or even forced to sell or be moved.
Some things that surprised me:
-Milwaukee's $81 million payroll surprised me as I thought it would be lower. (And, think, $10 mill of that is for Eric Gagne. Yikes.)
-The White Sox are spending $121 million. That's more than the Angels or Cubs. There's a whole lotta bad contracts on the South Side.
-Arizona is a favorite to win the National League with a payroll of $66 million. That is one well-run team.
-Pittsburgh at $49 million? Ownership needs to make that team a contender.
PAYROLLS:
N.Y. Yankees -- $209,081,579
Detroit -- 138,685,197
New York Mets -- 138,293,378
Boston -- 133,440,037
Chicago White Sox -- 121,152,667
Los Angeles Angels -- 119,216,333
Chicago Cubs -- 118,595,833
Los Angeles Dodgers -- 118,536,038
Seattle -- 117,993,982
Atlanta -- 102,424,018
St. Louis -- 100,624,450
Toronto -- 98,641,957
Philadelphia -- 98,269,881
Houston -- 88,930,415
Milwaukee -- 81,004,167
Cleveland -- 78,970,067
San Francisco -- 76,904,500
Cincinnati -- 74,277,695
San Diego -- 73,677,617
Colorado -- 68,655,500
Texas -- 68,239,551
Baltimore -- 67,196,248
Arizona -- 66,202,713
Minnesota -- 62,182,767
Kansas City -- 58,245,500
Washington -- 54,961,000
Pittsburgh -- 49,365,283
Oakland -- 47,967,126
Tampa Bay -- 43,820,598
Florida -- 21,836,500